2024 Open Table Diners’ Choice Award!
Tipsy Mermaid
Tonight's Special
Party Starters
- 4 Wives of Hemingway Ceviche
Ceviche with shrimp, conch, scallop, mahi. Mango sweet & habanero spicy. Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips.
$18.00 - Bikini Lettuce Wraps
Gulf shrimp & grilled pineapple salsa, island slaw, toasted coconut, habanero pickled onions
$18.00 - Brie & Blue Flatbread
olive oil, soft Brie cheese, grilled chicken, arugula, blueberry reduction
$16.00 - Buffalo Shrimp
1/2 pound beer battered gulf shrimp bites with spicy bird pepper buffalo sauce, gorgonzola crème
$9.00 - Caprese Flatbread
pesto, burrata cheese, roasted tomatoes, parmesan, romano, asiago cheeses, balsamic reduction
$16.00 - Coconut Crack Conch
A Caribbean delicacy, habanero guava dipping sauce with island slaw
$18.00 - Coconut Shrimp
Island slaw, habanero guava marmalade dipping sauce
$9.00 - Conch & Shrimp Fritters
Habanero guava marmalade & key lime mustard
$21.00 - Crispy Chicken Sliders
3 crispy chicken sliders on Hawaiian slider rolls with bacon, ranch, crispy pickles, fried jalapeño with small order of fries
$9.00 - Cuban Cigars
3 flour tortillas filled with mojo pork, honey ham, swiss cheese, crispy pickles, flash-fried, and key lime mustard
$9.00 - Figgy Flatbread
caramelized onions, gorgonzola, arugula, fig reduction
$16.00 - Fish Dip
Cool & creamy smoked gulf shrimp dip topped with pickled onions, red peppers, fried jalapeños, and blue corn tortilla chips
$9.00 - Marky Mark
Cuban bread crostini with mojo steak, horseradish crème, scallions, and balsamic reduction
$18.00 - Meat Lover Flatbread
bacon, ham, house made ranch, caramelized onions, white cheddar, arugula
$16.00 - Medianoche Sliders
3 Cubano sliders on Hawaiian rolls with Mojo pork, honey ham, crispy pickles, Swiss cheese, house mustards with Cuban black beans & rice
$9.00 - Miss Key West Drunken Shrimp
Beer steamed peel 'n eats, tequila lime cocktail sauce, Cuban bread for dipping. Caught from the only shrimp boat in Key West's Marina, the 'Miss Key West'
$18.00 - Off the Hook Pickles
Beer battered, key lime mustard & secret frita sauce
$9.00 - Steak Carpaccio
Thinly sliced rare steak, Parmesan, Romano & asiago, fried capers, arugula, horseradish crème, and truffle oil
$16.00
Salads & Chowder
- Bahama Village Conch Chowder
Key West style with conch, tomatoes, potatoes, and pork
$10.00 - Burrata Panzanella
Cuban bread croutons, mixed greens, grape tomatoes, crushed pistachios, white balsamic dressing, creamy burrata cheese & balsamic reduction
$16.00 - Caesar
Chopped romaine, creamy Caesars dressing, Parmesan, Romano & asiago, Cuban bread croutons
$11.00 - Hemingway House
Chopped romaine, fried avocado, red pepper, applewood smoked bacon, queso fresco, Cuban bread croutons, toasted coconut, pineapple mojito dressing
$14.00 - Steak Salad
Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, white balsamic dressing, mojo steak, gorgonzola, and shoestring potatoes
$18.00 - Wedge
Iceberg wedge, grape tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, gorgonzola, pickled onions, balsamic reduction, gorgonzola dressing
$12.00
Sandwiches
- Ana's Cubano Mix
Mojo pork, honey ham, crispy pickles, swiss cheese, house mustard, Cuban bread
$18.00 - Frita Burger
2 pork & beef Cuban smash patties, swiss cheese, shoestring potatoes, secret frita sauce, over easy egg, brioche bun
$18.00 - Dockside BLT
Blackened or beer battered mahi mahi, applewood smoked bacon, mixed greens, tomato, key lime tartar, grilled sourdough
$22.00 - Lazy Way Lane Mahi Mahi
Blackened or beer battered mahi mahi, habanero guava marmalade, island slaw, guacamole, shoestring potatoes, and brioche bun
$22.00 - Mahi Mahi Reuben
Blackened or beer battered mahi mahi, 1000 island slaw, swiss cheese, horseradish crème, grilled sourdough
$22.00 - Papa's Steak Sandwich
Mojo steak, sriracha honey, caramelized bacon & onions, fried jalapeños, shredded lettuce, horseradish crème, Cuban bread
$28.00 - Shipwreck Burger
2 pork & beef Cuban smash patties, mojo pork, lettuce, caramelized onions & mushrooms, Swiss cheese, gorgonzola crème, grilled sourdough
$18.00 - Spicy Rooster
Crispy chicken tossed in spicy bird pepper buffalo sauce, fried jalapeños, lettuce, gorgonzola crème, crispy pickles, and brioche bun
$16.00 - Truman Po' Boy
Beer battered gulf shrimp, Cajun remoulade, lettuce, tomatoes, crispy pickles, Cuban bread
$18.00 - Cheeseburger in Paradise
2 juicy pork and beef patties with lettuce and tomato, pickles, Heinz 57 & crispy potato fries. Just the way Jimmy Buffett liked it.
$18.00 - Last Flight Out Caesar Wrap
Blackened Key West shrimp, romaine, cherry tomatoes, house made Caesar dressing, Cuban bread croutons.
$18.00 - Wrap Me Up, Papa
Certified Angus Beef chimichurri steak, mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, red peppers, white balsamic
$22.00
Party Time
- 305 Seafood Pasta
Squid ink pasta, gulf shrimp, bay scallops, fire-roasted tomatoes, burrata cheese, parmesan, Romano & asiago, white wine garlic pesto sauce
$29.00 - A Moveable Feast Bowl
Cuban black beans & rice, mojo pork, pickled onions, guacamole, mango & jicama escabeche, fried jalapeños, grilled pineapple salsa, queso fresco
$19.00 - Boca Gnocchi
Smoked salmon, fire-roasted tomatoes, sautéed vegetables, fried capers, creamy lemon dill sauce
$26.00 - Fish 'N Chips
Beer battered Pacific Cod, Island slaw, key lime tartar sauce
$28.00 - Island Life Tacos
Beer battered or sautéed gulf shrimp, grilled pineapple salsa, island slaw, guacamole, pickled onions, sriracha honey, queso fresco, with black beans & rice, chips & salsa
$19.00 - LA Trattoria Gnocchi
Mushroom gorgonzola cream sauce
$21.00 - Papa's Pilar Basket
Beer battered gulf shrimp, bay scallops, Caribbean conch & shrimp fritters, fries, island slaw, sweet chili marmalade & Cajun remoulade
$32.00 - Seafood & Grits
Gulf shrimp, Maine scallops, creamy gruyère grits, bacon & wild mix mushrooms, coconut rum glaze or Southern Caribbean style
$31.00 - Surf 'N Turf Tacos
2 soft tortillas with a layer of cheese filled with steak tossed in chimichurri and blackened shrimp served with a side of Cuban black beans and rice with blue corn chips and salsa
$23.00 - The Calvin Coolidge Steak & Frites
Grilled & sliced 9 oz mojo center cut sirloin steak, chimichurri, crispy fries, gruyère fondue, mini Caesar salad
$31.00